Why I Use Herbs Instead of Essential Oils: Know the Difference
In the world of natural living, essential oils have become immensely popular. They’re touted for their aromatic qualities and powerful properties. But as a modern homesteader trying to love a more toxic-free life, I’ve found myself turning more often to whole herbs instead. In this post, I’ll share the reasons behind that choice, the nuances that differentiate herbs from essential oils, and how I integrate herbs into my everyday routine.
Why I Prefer Herbs Instead of Essential Oils
1. Whole-Plant Balance
Using the entire herb allows you to benefit from all the plant’s compounds working together. This synergy means the naturally occurring chemicals can balance one another out, reducing the chance of side effects. This also means that they work better than the sum of their parts.
Essential oils, on the other hand, are highly concentrated extracts—often focusing on just one part of the plant’s chemical profile, which can make them incredibly potent but also more prone to causing irritation or other issues.
2. Reduced Risk of Overuse and Irritation
Essential oils are ultra-concentrated. A little truly goes a long way, which is why misuse can lead to skin burns, esophageal burns (if ingested incorrectly), and other adverse allergic reactions. Herbs are generally gentler, especially when used in cooking, teas, or salves. If you choose to use essential oils, it’s crucial to dilute them in a carrier oil (e.g., olive, jojoba, or almond oil) and exercise caution—especially around children or individuals with sensitive skin.
3. Sustainability and Resource Efficiency
It can take large quantities of plant material to produce a small bottle of essential oil, raising concerns about sustainability and resource use. Whole herbs require far fewer raw materials, making them a more eco-friendly choice for everyday cooking and home remedies. If you’re aiming for a greener lifestyle, this is a major consideration.
4. Everyday Culinary and Medicinal Versatility
Herbs aren’t just for tinctures or salves; they’re also your best friend in the kitchen. Whether you’re adding oregano to pasta sauce or steeping chamomile for a soothing bedtime tea, you can seamlessly incorporate herbs into your daily life without extra effort. This makes them incredibly versatile—you get flavor plus potential health benefits in every cup or plate.
I do not recommend ingesting essential oils unless guided by a medical professional, so they are not a part of my daily kitchen routine.
5. Honoring Tradition and Cultural Practices
Many traditional healing systems and cultural practices rely on whole herbs in teas, poultices, or infusions. While essential oils can play a role, they’re generally less common in older, time-honored remedies. By embracing herbs, you’re tapping into a rich tapestry of traditional knowledge.
Herbal Safety Basics: How to Research and Vet Herbs for Your Family
Learn about what herbalism is (and isn’t), some herbal safety basics, and how to research and vet herbs before using them with your family.
How I Still Use Essential Oils (Occasionally)
- Aromatherapy: I might diffuse a few drops when the house needs freshening—especially if we’re dealing with strong odors from illness or cooking.
- Natural Scent Boosters: If I’m gifting a homemade candle or skincare product to someone used to stronger fragrances, I’ll add a drop or two of an essential oil blend.
- Targeted Skincare: Certain products formulated with essential oils can help with specific issues like acne, but I ensure they’re well-diluted and from a reputable source.
- Supervised Medicinal Use: I have NOT had a case that I felt the need to use essential oils internally as medicine, but its not something I would rule out if prescribed by a professional.
FAQs About Herbs vs. Essential Oils
1. Can I use oil of oregano in the same way as dried oregano?
No. Oil of oregano (the essential oil) is extremely potent—similar in strength to antibiotics. Dried or fresh oregano used in cooking or teas is much gentler and better suited for everyday use. I even infuse my own oregano oil at home and prefer to use that as a remedy if needed.
2. Are essential oils safe to ingest?
Generally, it’s not recommended unless you’re under the supervision of a trained professional. Essential oils can cause serious internal harm if misused.
3. What’s the best way to start using herbs at home?
- Add them to your favorite dishes (soups, stews, sauces).
- Brew herbal teas (mint, chamomile, lemon balm).
- Experiment with infused oils and vinegars.
- Try making simple salves for skincare.
Herbal Projects Without Essential Oils
Final Thoughts
Choosing between herbs and essential oils doesn’t have to be an all-or-nothing decision. Both have valid uses, but it’s important to understand their differences. Herbs tend to be gentler, more sustainable, and easier to incorporate into everyday meals and natural remedies. Essential oils can be wonderfully aromatic and potent, but they require more caution and knowledge to use safely.
Grab your Free Routine
The 15 Minute Homestead Routine (for busy days).
Want a simple morning rhythm that keeps your home running, your garden growing, and your goals on track? Grab my free 15-Minute Morning Routine Worksheets—designed to help you build homestead habits that stick.
In my experience, a whole-plant approach fits perfectly into a relaxed homestead lifestyle. If you’re curious and want to learn more, I invite you to join our conversation in The Homestead Challenge community—an inclusive space where city dwellers and suburban homesteaders share tips, recipes, and ideas for living more sustainably.
Join the Community
We would love to see what you have created so mention us @brittanylgibson on Instagram or join the Facebook community!
I’d love to hear how you incorporate herbs into your daily life! Leave a comment or share your favorite ways to use herbs and essential oils responsibly.
Pin it for Later!
About the Author
Brittany Gibson is a modern suburban homesteader and the founder of The Homestead Challenge. She empowers women to adopt a simpler, more self-sufficient lifestyle, feeling confident to grow, create, and thrive on their own terms with joy and balance.
Read more about my transformation and join me in building our lives from scratch.
